Five Interesting Facts About Wilhelm Richard Wagner

Wagner month is about to begin in the the Washington, DC area.  The Virginia Opera’s production of The Flying Dutchman plays in Fairfax on Saturday and Sunday.  The Washington National Opera’s ambitious production of the Ring cycle kicks off on the following Saturday and will continue for three weeks.  All performances are listed in the sidebar (or at the bottom of the page on some mobile devices).  Who was this composer who many claim is the world’s greatest music genius?  I thought I’d present you with five interesting facts about Richard Wagner to hopefully interest you a bit more to listen to his music and to learn more.  To say that Wagner led an interesting life is a massive understatement; so here goes, five facts about Wagner that I find interesting:

Fact oneThere is some controversy about who was Wagner’s father.  Officially, his father was Karl Friedrich Wagner, a police official in Leipzig, Germany.  Ludwig Geyer, an actor and family friend took over the family’s affairs when Karl died; Richard was six months-old.  A year later, Geyer married his mother; six months passed and a daughter was born to the happy couple.  There was a strong attachment and resemblance between Richard and Ludwig, and there was other circumstantial evidence that Geyer was the real papa.  However, what is interesting to me is that this controversy seems to be driven by the class-conscious belief that a mere policeman could not have fathered this artistic genius, and an actor, who demonstrated some creativity and classical interest, is a more likely gene donor, but it importantly is also driven by claims, in the absence of evidence, that Geyer had been Jewish.  No paternity testing in those days.

Fact two: Wagner was not a music prodigy, such as say, Mozart.  His rise to music stardom only began at age 29, and was not yet spectacular then, and turned really successful only after he turned fifty.  His first love was actually literature.  However, at about age 15, he turned to music after being inspired by Carl Maria von Weber’s Der Freischutz, yes, one of the operas in the 2016-2017 season for Virginia Opera.  He lost interest in school per se to devote himself to music and got kicked out.  He was a self-taught musician and finally had six months of formal music study at 18, which eventually enabled him to get conductor posts with troubled opera companies.  His demanding nature and resisting of popular sentiments got him fired from those.  His last, before moving to Paris was in Riga, Russia, which eventually led to him having to sneak out of the country to flee to Paris.  He and his wife lived in poverty and debt in his early years in Paris, despite having a popular opera composer, Giacomo Meyerbeer, as his champion.

Fact three: Wagner once said, “No more, Mr. Nice Guy!”; he was six weeks-old at the time.  Okay, I am stretching the truth by calling this a fact, but most of the people who knew him would have said that it was possible it happened.  In Wagner’s view, he was the greatest artist ever, and being totally dedicated to his art, the world was there to meet his needs, with the only reciprocation being his great works of art.  He was always true to his art, but as a person, he lied, borrowed money with no intention of paying back, was ruthless in dealing with others, had affairs with married women even as his and their spouses knew, even when the spouses were his benefactors, generally criticized and flaunted the mores of his day, and was strongly anti-Semitic.  Though his death occurred fifty years before the Third Reich, Hitler adopted his music as the theme song for Nazi Germany.  As best as I can tell, his music is still not played in Israel; when orchestras there have scheduled any of his pieces, they were forced by popular outcry to renege.  Now you understand the importance of the issue of his paternity.  Each of us has to deal with how an artist’s personal life and attributes influence our willingness or ability to enjoy their artistic achievements.  If we can’t tolerate someone’s work based on their character, it is usually not an intellectual decision.

Fact four: A king took away Wagner's troubles and freed his creative powers.  King Lugwig II of Bavaria befriended and sponsored Wagner, beginning soon after he turned fifty.  Ludwig II was eighteen years-old and loved Wagner’s music; he paid all of Wagner’s debts and gave him a living allowance, and helped support his future musical production efforts.  In essence, Wagner won the lottery (next MegaMillions drawing is Friday and PowerBall Is Saturday).  I have read that Lugwig II was also homosexual and Wagner may have provided him more than musical service, not a requirement for the lotteries as far as I know.  Ludwig II is an interesting story in himself.

Fact fiveOne of Wagner’s major achievements was made outside of composing, the opera house at Bayreuth, Germany (Bavaria), the Bayreuth Festival Theater.  King Ludwig enabled Wagner to complete the opera theater that Wagner desired to premiere his operas.  He designed it as an amphitheater with a recessed orchestra pit, departing from the usual arrangements of his day.  He may have stolen the design idea from a Munich architect, no attribution of course.  It opened with the premiere of the Ring cycle in 1876.  To this day, a famous and highly lauded opera festival, the Bayreuth Festival, is held there each year, drawing the top names in opera.  If you follow opera at all, it will not be long before you encounter the name Beyreuth.  Wagner is buried in a garden a few miles from the opera house.

And I haven’t mentioned his period of exile, his marrying the illegitimate daughter of famous composer Franz Liszt, or his sixteen volumes of prose.  I will simply close with a quote from Shakespeare (Macbeth), that I read in “Ticket to the Opera” by Phil G. Goulding, as applied to Wagner: “Such welcome and unwelcome things at once, ‘tis hard to reconcile.”

 

WETA PBS Channel in DC to Broadcast Rigoletto on Saturday

In my blog post, “Affordable Opera, Part 2,” I discussed the broadcast of Met Opera videos periodically by PBS television stations: “A great way to view many of these [Met Opera] videos for free is to tune into the Great Performances at the Met broadcasts on PBS television.  Check here to track these down in your area.  I simply have my DVR set to record Great Performances at the Met.  Over the last two years I have recorded about 25 opera performances this way.  I find viewing these on my own devices has a few advantages:  I can pause the videos when I leave the room, or I can watch them in portions and even watch them multiple times; also, when I miss something, I can use my remote control to go back a few seconds to see it again.  Of course, the selection on PBS is limited and the availability is episodic.”

On this Saturday, April 23, at 11 am, WETA PBS station in Washington DC will broadcast Rigoletto, which was originally broadcast by the Metropolitan Opera in Cinemas on May 17, 2013; this is a re-broadcast.  The broadcast is not part of the Met's regular series.  Set your recording devices if you get this channel.  It is free!!!

First of all, Rigoletto is a great Verdi opera.  For much of my early opera love, it was my favorite opera.  It has a great story with a surprise and tragic ending, and some really beautiful, dramatic music.  If you haven’t seen it, this is a good chance.  The story for this production is moved from regal times to the Las Vegas era of Frank Sinatra's Rat Pack.  It is an interesting transformation.  It stars Piotr Beczala, a leading modern tenor, and Diana Damrau, a current diva.  I saw this production in a cinema broadcast.  I highly recommend it.  In the broadcast I saw, one of those unanticipated moments happened.  Diana Damrau was being interviewed by Rene Fleming, another modern day diva.  Ms.Damrau has two children.  They allowed her young son to join her on stage.  The transformation was amazing.  This regal diva instantaneously changed to a mirthful Bavarian mom when her son joined her.  Ms. Damrau comes across as Gilda in Rigoletto, as a pliable character, but then look at her power and the beauty of her voice as she plays the Queen of Night in Mozart’s The Magic Flute in the clip below from Youtube.com (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpVV9jShEzU). .

Saturday Roundup of Things Opera

Here are a few operas items of note to scan through at your weekend’s leisure:

James Levine, Principal Conductor of the Met Orchestra, Announces Retirement-

After a forty year career at the Metropolitan Opera, principal conductor, James Levine will step down from his current position at the end of this season to become music director emeritus.  He is credited with having built the Met Orhcestra into the eminence it enjoys today.  Michael Cooper in the NYTImes covers the event, and some history with Levine in a very good article published 4/14/16: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/15/arts/music/james-levine-transformative-at-the-met-opera-is-stepping-down.html?_r=0.  Anne Midgette wrote a critical article for Friday’s edition of the Post that points out the general sentiment of apparently most opera professionals that it was past time for him to step down: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/style/wp/2016/04/14/met-opera-announces-levines-departure-long-overdue/

Into Binge Watching?  How about 17 hours of Wagner?

The Washington Post's classical music critic demonstrates that she has a humorous side with a fun article that discusses the demands of the upcoming Washington National Opera production of the Ring, four nights of 4 to 5 hours of opera watching each, but makes the case it is worthy of the effort.  I plan to take a pillow, a snack, and something to help me with the anxiety caused by 17 hours without checking my iPhone.  https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/music/looking-for-your-next-binge-watching-marathon-try-17-hours-of-opera/2016/04/14/52b756e0-00cc-11e6-9203-7b8670959b88_story.html 

How Old is Too Old?

Opera authority, Fred Plotkin, has just published an article discussing the issues around the effects of aging on opera’s performers, performances, and managers.  Very good at touching on all the points, maybe less so for staking out a position.  You decide.  I agree with him that the key factor should be whether the performer can play the part and sing the role correctly and convincingly.  After uploading my post on the return of Kathleen Battle, I sent it to Ms. Midgette.  To my surprise and delight, she read it and responded.  I learned from her that opera singers with a light voice sometimes have their voice change when they move into their forties and that may have been a factor for Ms. Battle.  Ah yes, time will have its way.  http://www.wqxr.org/#!/story/how-old-too-old-opera-stage/ 

Don’t Forget the Dutchman Has Begun His Flight

If you check the sidebar, you will see the remaining chances to see Wagner’s The Flying Dutchman.  The first performance that took place in Norfolk has been reviewed.  It generally received high marks for the singers and orchestra, but the direction was criticized, such that some scenes did not come off as intended.  http://pilotonline.com/entertainment/arts/theater/review-virginia-opera-s-the-flying-dutchman-delivers-plenty-for/article_a8cd127a-018f-5d00-a959-9fc9b8daaae1.html 

Roberto Devereux Who?

In case you have finished or can take a break from doing your taxes this weekend, Met Opera will be broadcasting the Met performance of Roberto Devereux into theaters live in HD this Saturday – see the sidebar.  The main attraction here clearly is Sandra Radvanovsky who is completing her hat trick of starring in all three of Donizetti’s operas about Tudor queens.  Earlier this season, she played the queens in Anna Bolena and Maria Stuarda.  She plays Queen Elizabeth I this time, whose love interest is nobleman, Robert Devereux.  The HD recording of this broadcast will play in theaters the next Wednesday evening.  I saw her star in Anna Bolena a couple of years ago at the Kennedy Center.  Now that I know what it means, I can say she has a stentorian voice.  She has what is known as a big instrument; voices in the opera world are known as instruments.  It is also a very pleasing voice.  This is a chance to see an outstanding soprano play a role she is known for, at a cost of about $25, in the comfort of a theater with a big screen.

Opera Philadelphia’s 2016-2017 Season: It’s Complicated

In a way, it’s not that complicated at first glance.  There are two sure fire money makers, Turandot and The Marriage of Figaro.  Fair enough.  And two headline sopranos, Stephanie Blythe and Christine Goerke, also money makers.  Then there is Tancredi, a tip of the hat to a highly-regarded, though less often produced, work of Rossini.  Now the real adventure begins: offered is a new take on Macbeth (tickets are already being reported as scarce).  Add a world premiere of a new opera based on the critically-acclaimed movie of the same name, Breaking the Waves, which contains some explicit language and sexual content that requires a warning label.  Aside from the operas themselves, there is the shell game: the opera venues shift.  And there is the odd scheduling – three of the operas sit on top of each other at the end of September.  It looks to get even odder, and maybe even more exciting, in 2017-2018; parents take note - a production of The Magic Flute is in the works.  We will sort this all out. 

Daniel Patrick Stearn, classical music critic for the Philadelphia Inquirer has reviewed the upcoming season, recommended reading for the information about the collaborations involved in these productions.  Maybe I am wrong, but I think I detected slight consternation and only mild support for the addition of Breaking the Waves.

Here is the lineup for 2016-2017 :

  • Macbeth by Fabrizio Cassol, after Giuseppe Verde, Sep 24 – 25..…Prince Theater
  • Breaking the Waves by Missy Mazzoli, Sep 22 – Oct 1…..Perelman Theater
  • Turandot by Giocomo Puccini, Sep 23 – Oct 2…..Academy of Music
  • Tancredi by Gioacchino Rossini, Feb 10 – 19…..Academy of Music
  • The Marriage of Figaro by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Apr 28 – May 7….Academy of Music

Philly is a great city to visit and I get a really good feeling about Opera Philadelphia.  You might also want to refer to my earlier post about this company (“A Mini Opera Vacation to Philly and the Excitement of New Opera”).  I have by no means gotten my head around this or any other opera company as yet, but it seems a little crazy in a good way.  They also seem to have an active arts community that genuinely reaches out to its fans.  I get a feeling of excitement and vibrancy that bodes well for the future for the mid-Atlantic opera fan.  As evidence, they are planning to start the 2017-2018 season with a festival they are calling O17, six operas in 12 days and many other events.  They say this year’s scheduling of three operas at the end of September is a practice run.  Their website also justifiably boasts that Opera Philadelphia is the only American opera company to be nominated in the Best Opera Company category for the International Opera Awards for 2016.  For us fans, the next couple of years are going to be a fun ride.

Macbeth is a joint venture with The FringeArts of Philadelphia, which is making this production part of their own festival; Opera Philadelphia’s supply of tickets for this is limited, so buy early.  My first reaction to this Macbeth is this: who does Mr. Fabrizio Cassol think he is putting his name ahead of Verdi’s?  I think he is at least a dozen great operas behind to be doing that.  Beyond that overreaction which probably isn’t his fault anyway, this version of Macbeth is actually a touring production since 2014 of the Third World Bun organization, whose founder, Brett Bailey, is the director and creative force behind the concept for this theatrical production of Macbeth.  Opera Philadelphia says this is the American world premiere of the production, though the tour’s website lists Fairfield University as a venue just before.  The website states that Verdi’s score has been reworked by Mr. Cassol and adapted for 12 onstage musicians and it is performed by 10 South African opera singers; I’m feeling kinder towards Mr. Cassol, a little.  The story is gripping and important, set in the Congo amid the wars and political upheavals there.  A group of people find a trunk of costumes and use it to tell their story.  The London Telegraph gave the performance there five stars. The setting gives this production potentially powerful dramatic appeal dealing with the very human and inhuman mayhem in portions of today’s Africa.

The composer for Breaking the Waves is Missy Mazzoli.  She is an American contemporary composer known for chamber, orchestral, and operatic work.  Her chamber opera, Song from the Uproar was performed last year by the LA Opera.  From 2012-2015, she was composer-in-residence at Opera Philadelphia.  She also has an electro-acoustic band, Victoire, that plays her music.  This will be interesting.  I’ve listened to some of her music on iTunes.  It is hard to envision this as opera.  I was intrigued by a statement she made in a promotional video that she could use music to say things that the words were not saying.  That sounds like opera.  If I can work it out, I will probably try to go, to feed my thirst for new opera.  “Breaking the Waves,” the movie, had strong sexual content involving loyalty and morality, hence the warning label for the opera.  (Hmmm.  Appomattox last year at the Kennedy Center had more than its share of foul language and I don’t remember a warning, but then, it didn’t have sex.)  I applaud Opera Philadelphia for giving young composers a chance.  Let’s support the venture and hope it works.

Tancredi was the great Italian composer Gioacchino Rossini’s first opera seria success. He is better known for his comedic operas, such as the Barber of Seville.  I knew his William Tell Overture from his opera, Guillaume Tell, as a child – it was the theme song for the Lone Ranger and we all quickly learned the scary story of a dad shooting the apple off his son’s head with a bow and arrow.  Tancredi is based on a play, "Tancrede," by Voltaire; it tells the story of star-crossed lovers caught in family and historical conflict between Syracuse (Sicily, not NY) and the Saracens.  Rossini actually wrote two endings, a happy one and a sad one.  The opera seria form of the day required a happy ending, but keeping true to Voltaire’s play required a tragic ending.  The tragic one seems to have survived the test of time.  Too bad, with what is going on in the world today, I think I’d prefer a happy ending.  A big draw for this performance is the major star, mezzo-soprano Stephanie Blythe, who according to Mr. Stearns requested this opera, and perhaps surprisingly, though not unusual for Rossini operas, plays our hero, Tancredi, in a pants role.

I have covered Turandot and The Marriage of Figaro previously, also being performed next season by the Virginia Opera and the Washington National Opera, respectively.  Interestingly, the Turandot production features well-known soprano Christine Goerke in the title role.  She starred in the performance I saw at the Met last October.  She was excellent.  Mr. Stearns said her voice was stentorian (I had to look it up).  That adjective certainly also applies to Ms. Blythe in Tancredi.  Turandot offers the chance for the soprano who plays Liu to steal the show; Joyce El-Khoury will play Liu; evidence of her chops is provided by the fact she will play Violetta in La Traviata in a Royal Opera House production next Jan/Feb.  The spectacular staging at the Met was nothing less than performance art.  I’m tempted to go just to see the staging by Opera Phildelphia. Figaro will feature Cecilia Hall as Cherubino, who I very much enjoyed as Ruby in Opera Philadelphia’s Cold Mountain.  If you haven’t seen Figaro lately, go please yourself again. 

Tickets:  First, an admission: I have never run across instructions that I didn’t misunderstand some part of or a form that I didn’t make a mistake filling out, usually signing below the line when I should have signed above, or vice versa.  So when I say I find Opera Philadelphia’s otherwise outstanding website difficult to decipher in regard to tickets, consider my admission.  After considerable effort, I think I have figured it out.  Right now they are only offering subscription packages.  There are two basic packages:  Fixed seat and flexible packages.  However, under the Fixed Seat package there are two series, the Academy Series and the Perelman Theater Series (they call this the Aurora Series), a little confusing to sell this as a package since the Aurora Series only has one opera, Breaking the Waves.  Fixed Seat package subscribers can buy separate tickets for Macbeth at the same time.  Now, for the flexible packages that they call the Select Series, you can choose a package of three or more operas from among the five operas being presented; they will also sell you a flexible package of just two operas.  All package prices are discounted over individual seat prices and offer ticket exchange, a pretty good deal.  Prices for the Opera at the Academy package of three operas range from $51 to $645.  The theater is not small in terms of number of seats, but is cozy and I suspect most seats are good.  If you require extra leg room, I recommend you buy box seats.  I didn’t see any discounts for students, but they are offering a free opera simulcast of Turandot on Independence Mall for the Oct 1 production; registration and tickets are required.  There is also a Gala Opening Celebration if you have the bucks.  Page 22-23 of the season brochure provides a most helpful overview; use full screen mode to read.  Tickets for individual performances go on sale August 1.  If you'd like a person to help with selecting/purchasing packages, call Guest Services at 215-732-8400.

 

Opera in the Movies Series: "Philadelphia" and How to Listen to Opera

A friend suggested to me that opera in the movies might be a good blog topic, and I agreed.  I found a number of good articles available online that covered just that.  Many use the premise that they are showing readers that they, the readers, are more familiar with opera than they realize.  One article by Justin Moss published by the Huffington Post in 2012 is particularly to be recommended.  As I scanned through these articles it finally struck me that I was, well…, scanning through these articles.  I suspect that is what most of us do when we see the 'ten what ever' articles: we scan quickly to be reminded of examples we already can guess and see the ones we don’t.  In doing so, we miss out on much of what they have to offer.  So, I have decided to make Opera in the Movies a series for OperaGene, not one blog post, and to take a more in-depth look at each example.

For the premiere episode of my Opera in the Movies Series, I chose a scene from the 1993 movie “Philadelphia” starring Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington.  This movie also has one of my favorite pop recordings, Bruce Springsteen’s song, Streets of Philadelphia.  In the movie, gay lawyer Andrew Beckett (Hanks) is aided by homophobic lawyer Joe Miller (Washington) in defending Beckett in a wrongful termination law suit, charging his law firm with firing him because he had contracted AIDS.  In the 1980s and most of the 1990s, contracting AIDS was a death sentence and victims suffered a great deal of discrimination due to public fear and misunderstanding.  Now, thanks to research sponsored by the National Institutes of Health and America’s pharmaceutical companies, sufferers can lead a fairly normal life on now available maintenance medications.  NIH still sponsors research to develop a vaccine total cure and some efforts appear to offer hope.

In the movie, Miller at first rejects Beckett’s plea for help, but yields when he witnesses the discrimination that Beckett is enduring.  Ok, no more spoiler information in case you have not seen the movie.  In the scene below taken from Youtube, Andrew says to Joe, “Do you like opera, Joe?”.  Miller deflects the question, answering that he is not that familiar opera.  As I watched this very dramatic moment, it struck me that this was the best lesson in how to watch opera that I had yet to run across.  Watch it before reading further:

The line in that sequence that most affects me is Beckett saying “That single cello!”.  How about you?  In this video I think you can see how the drama and tension of the story, the pinpointing of feelings with the words, and the evocation and modulation of emotion by the music combine to provide an overwhelming sensory experience that can transport you to that human moment in time, allowing you to experience what your human compatriots have experienced while also experiencing the transcendent beauty of life.  No one can really tell you how to listen to opera.  Experts can tell you what to listen for, but until you listen in the way that Andrew listens, caught up and without evaluation or judgment, you haven’t really listened to opera.  Once you listen that way, it is highly likely you will return for more.  I'm betting Joe started attending operas.

Kathleen Battle: A Powerful Story, As Yet Not Told

About four years ago, one year into the beginning of my love of opera, I was making my morning commute to work at NIH.  Heading out of Vienna onto the Beltway, I switched from weather and traffic reporting to Met Opera radio, and Donizetti’s Elisir D’Amore had just begun, a good, frisky opera to get you ready for a workday.  I was pleased, and I recognized Pavarotti right away, such a distinctive voice, but who was the lead soprano?  What a voice!  I should add that I am very much into voices.  If I don’t like the voice, I find it hard to enjoy the singing no matter how technically correct.  This soprano’s voice was like ice cream, sweet and flavorful.  She moved through the scale effortlessly without revealing any strain; even in the highest registers, the voice always maintained its flavor.  As soon as I was able, I tracked down the performance and identified the soprano – Kathleen Deanna Battle, highly acclaimed lyric coloratura soprano.  I became a big fan, eager to find recordings of other operas in which she had performed.  It turned out the supply was surprisingly limited.

Some facts from Wikipedia and a number of news reports (list available on request):  Born in 1948, she grew up in Ohio, the youngest of seven children.  Her father was a steelworker and her mother sang gospel music at church.  Her talent was recognized as a child and mentors moved her in the direction of music.  She chose to study music education at the University of Cincinnati and taught 5th and 6th grades for awhile.  Her professional singing debut was in 1972 at the Festival of Two Worlds in Spoleto, Italy, which she garnered though an audition.  Her early singing career involved touring with major orchestras.  Her operatic debut was in 1975 with the Michigan Opera singing Rosina in The Barber of Seville.  Her first appearance at the Met Opera was in 1977 with James Levine conducting, still principal conductor of the Met orchestra today.  She had been befriended by Mr. Levine earlier in her career, beginning a relationship that has apparently endured.  She became a mainstay at the Met during the 1980s, performing over 224 times in 14 different operas.  She was also featured at many other top opera houses in the U.S. and world.  Early she was criticized for having a light voice in terms of power, but her voice grew with experience.  You can listen here to her sing a famous aria from The Barber of Seville, titled “Una voce poca fa.”

During the nineties her reputation for diva behavior grew even as demand for her performances surged.  She recorded many albums of songs and arias and did recitals of different types of music in addition to appearing in operas.  However, reports of her being difficult to work with circulated widely.  She was reported to have thrown another soprano’s clothes into the hallway because she wanted that particular dressing room.  She apparently became highly critical of staff and other performers, even banning some from rehearsals.  Staff at the San Francisco Opera were reported to have worn T-shirts that stated, “I survived the Battle.” It was said that in rehearsals for a performance at the Met in February 1994, she refused to let the other performer look at her mouth during duets.  She was often late or failed to appear.  She had quit a production at the Met a year earlier when the Met manager did not appear at her demand.  This highly critical and odd behavior finally caused Met management to act that February, and she was dismissed, fired, for “unprofessional actions” in rehearsals, an extraordinary act for Met Opera, especially since this was her last performance under contract at the time with the Met. 

Ms. Battle never owned up to any unprofessional behavior on her part then or later, no apology to anyone that I have seen.  An official response at the time from her management company claimed that no one told her about any unprofessional behavior and that she regretted the decision.  She went on to a very successful concert and recording career to the present day, singing a variety of music.  She has won a total of five Grammies and several other awards.  However, Ms. Battle never appeared in an opera on stage again!  What a stunning course of events!

Reading about all of this as part of my search for recordings of her opera performances solved the puzzle of why relatively few were available.  One of the most acclaimed sopranos of her day had voluntarily cut her opera career short, or possibly had been shut out of the system.  But nowhere was I able to read why it happened. I have looked in vain for a biography or any in depth explanation.  The NY Times suggested that being 45 at the time she could no longer play the ingénue roles, but 45 is not old for an opera singer.  In regard to suggestions that the opera houses would not hire her, I find it unlikely a talent this major could not have found one that would.  It would be one of the most effective blackballs ever.  Especially when you consider that she and James Levine, the head conductor and a man of considerable influence in the opera world, were friends and later business partners.  And at the time, management would not rule out a possible return.  It is also notable that I have not seen reports of diva behavior for her since the Met dismissal.  Maybe because of my early affection for her voice I have gotten too emotionally involved on some level, distorting my judgment.  Maybe it was simply that her ego got out of hand; she was fired; she got good offers for other types of performances and was mad at opera; maybe when she wanted to return, it was too late.  Maybe.  But, I think the inner workings of this personality have yet to be revealed.

What might she have achieved in opera if she had continued?  Surely, she would be a legend even now during her own time.  Up until I heard Renata Scotto play Cio Cio San in Madama Butterfly, Ms. Battle was my favorite opera voice; she is still number two.  I think everyone has a right to be who they are and live their life as it suits them, but as an opera fan I feel sad and deprived, much as I did when Whitney Houston stopped developing her talent.  And I truly long for revelations that will satisfy my need to understand what happened, whatever the truth is.  If anyone can shed further light, please comment.

At the age of 68, Ms. Battle will return to the stage at The Metropolitan Opera this coming Nov 13 for the first time in 22 years.  Her concert is titled, “Kathleen Battle: Underground Railroad — A Spiritual Journey.”  Her interest in spirituals is long standing, undoubtedly influenced by her mother; she paired with opera star Jessye Norman and Levine in 1991 to release a successful album titled, “Spirituals In Concert”and has other albums of spirituals.  She was finally lured back, after many attempts over several years, by Peter Gelb, the Met’s general manager.  Maybe she wanted to work one last time at the Met with Levine who is nearing the end of his career as principal conductor.  We will see if the wounds have healed enough for there to be some reconciliation with opera professionals and with opera fans.  I think it is potentially one of the most powerful stories yet to be told; Academy Awards will result.

Correction for the Apr 5 Post On Pittsburg Opera 2016-2017 Season

A reader pointed out to me, and it is much to my chagrin that I made a reporting error yesterday. About baseball, not opera.  I can handle making a mistake about opera.  The Pittsburgh Pirates do not play in Three Rivers Stadium any longer, in fact, not since 2000.  Ah, the danger of relying on memory at whatever age I am now.  The Pirates play in PNC Park slightly east of the intersection of the three rivers on the north shore of the Allegheny across from downtown.  The Pittsburgh Steelers football team, which also once played at Three Rivers Stadium, now play at Heinz Stadium, closer to the intersection.  I have made the appropriate edit in the Apr 5 post.

The Classics and a World Premiere: Pittsburgh Opera 2016-2017 Season

Pittsburgh is a 250-mile, four-hour, interstate drive away from DC and stretches my opera coverage of the mid-Atlantic about as far as I can manage.  But it is worth it.  I have been there several times, though not yet for opera.  Actually, I am bummed because I had so wanted to attend The Rake’s Progress there at the end of this month – see sidebar - but have chosen to attend the Ring Cycle of four operas at the Kennedy Center instead, and due to my time commitments can’t do both.  The setting for Pittsburgh is very dramatic: three rivers intersect; the Allegheny and the Monongahela come together to initiate the Ohio River.  The Pittsburgh Pirates baseball team plays close to the intersection, on the north shore of the Allegheny across from downtown.  Directly across the Monongahela, from the relatively flat center center is a line of tall bluffs that dominate the south-western skyline, forming a barrier to the encroachment of the Pittsburgh skyscrapers.  An opera mini-vacation to Pittsburgh is definitely in my queue for next year; and given my love of baseball, I suspect you will be able to guess which production I am targeting.

Pittsburgh Opera has announced its lineup for next year, its 78th season.  It has been reviewed by Elizabeth Bloom, classical music critic, for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette; I recommend reading her comments, especially to get details on the world premiere.

Here is the 2016-2017 lineup:

  • La Traviata by Giuseppe Verdi, Oct 8 - 16
  • Salome by Richard Strauss, Nov 5 - 13
  • Turandot by Giacomo Puccini, March 25 - April 2
  • The Summer King by Daniel Sonenberg, April 29 - May 7

La Traviata, Salome, and Turandot are, of course, classics in the standard repertoire.  The production of The Summer King by Daniel Sonenberg will be a world premiere.  Sonenberg is an associate professor and resident composer at the University of Southern Maine.  The opera was presented in concert format in Portland in 2014.  His other work appears to be songs and chamber music.  The opera revolves around Josh Gibson, a Pittsburgh native and a catcher in baseball’s Negro Leagues which performed in the first half of the twentieth century.  He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1972 and was considered the best power hitter of his generation in the Negro leagues.  He died in 1947 at the age of 35, just before the integration of the major leagues.  Had he been allowed to play in the majors, one can only wonder how his statistics would have compared to say, Babe Ruth.  The opera will feature a rare predominately black cast, including highly regarded, long time favorite, Denyce Graves.  Kudos to Pittsburgh opera for giving a new, modern opera a hearing on a major stage.  There is a serious risk the public will not respond and come out for an unknown opera, but hopefully, there of a lot of fans like me yearning for new opera.  This will be an interesting story to follow.

La Traviata gets my vote for best Verdi music, though there a lot of contenders and I may change my mind tomorrow.  Traviata is all about Violetta, the pure-hearted lady of pleasure with health issues who falls in love.  Danielle Pastin, a Pittsburgh resident will play Violetta.  She has appeared in major opera houses including the Met.  My family and I saw a modernized performance at the Met in 2014 with the excellent Marina Rebeka.  My favorite Violetta is Ileana Contrubas.  Check out this youtube video of her and a young Placido Domingo from 1981.  The recording is not of a great quality, but even so, I’m not sure who was prettier, Ms. Contrubas or Mr. Domingo.  I have not seen Salome, based on the biblical story, but definitely intend to at some point.  It is one of Richard Strauss’ psychological operas and merits some preparation; it is probably not one for the newbie.  Turandot is fine for a newbie.  See my comments on the Virginia Opera’s planned performance here. It has a famous tenor aria, Nessun Dorma.  You can listen to the great Luciano Pavarotti singing it here.

Pittsburgh Opera also plans two smaller operas, Frederic Handel’s Richard the Lionheart, circa 1719, and Laura Kaminsky’s As One, circa 2014, in smaller venues as part of the resident artist’s program.

Tickets: Season subscription tickets are now on sale.  Individual opera ticket sales will begin in August.  Season tickets for all four operas range from over $600 to under $50.  Ticket exchange is allowed for subscription holders. 

 

Be It Resolved: The Music In Opera Is More important Than The Words

Quick, who was the composer for the Marriage of Figaro, Don Giovanni, and Cosi Fan Tutte?  Of course you know it is Mozart.  Quick, who was the librettist for these operas?  Bet I gotcha, at least most of you.  Lorenzo Da Ponte was Mozart’s librettist for all three.  When operas are discussed, as oft as not, the librettist, the guy who writes the words, is overlooked.  Thus, Figaro has become known as a Mozart opera, not a Mozart-Da Ponte opera, for most people.  Why then does opera authority Fred Plotkin in his book, "Opera 101", p. 27, say that it is a great debate about which is more important, the music or the words?  One can find further evidence this is a debate by looking to the opera, Capriccio, by Richard Strauss.  Two suitors pursue the same woman.  One is a poet who plies her with words, the other a composer who attempts to seduce her with his music.  Throughout the opera they argue the issue and ask her to reveal her decision the next morning, by choosing the ending of an opera they have written together.  Spoiler alert: the last paragraph of this post reveals the ending of the opera.

I was reminded of this question the other day while doing internet searching for opera information.  My eye was attracted to a hit that stated, “Opera Stories…In Few Words, the Stories (divided into Acts) Of Over 100 Operas”.  It turned out to be a 1910 book by Henry Lowell Mason (a clear online copy can be found here), and the face page further makes the statement, “Most persons attending an Opera wish to know only its story without reading its entire libretto.” The book contains photos of opera stars of its day (check out Enrico Caruso on p. 15) and is interesting to thumb through.  I read a few of the synopses of operas I know and they seemed concise and accurate.  With brief effort, I was unable to find out anything about Mr. Mason himself.  Now, I haven’t seen any polls but I suspect he is correct in that historically most people have gone to see operas in languages they don’t know and read the summaries, but not the libretti, for the opera.  It would seem to make the compelling case that the words are not crucial for a satisfying experience.

Today one does not have to make that choice because almost all performances now show supertitles of the translations of the text above the stage (the well-to-do Met has them on the back of the seats in front of you).  I find that I choose to read the supertitles, but I also find them a distraction.  While reading, you miss something on the stage and in the music, and perhaps most importantly it represents a micro-break in one’s immersion in the opera; while improving one’s understanding of what just happened and is about to happen, one has lost the present.  When I listen to opera recordings on the radio I find the experience enjoyable, often without knowing the story.  In fact, I wonder if I have a better musical experience than a native speaker hearing the words and comprehending their meaning.  I wonder, for example, if Italians hear the beauty and fluidity of Italian operas the way I do, but perhaps it is the other way round.  I, personally, am not sure that listening to operas written in English is superior to listening to those in a foreign language.  I find that understanding the words both adds value and subtracts from the experience.  And to tell the truth, given the distortions of sung words, I find the supertitles necessary even for English operas.

Science reported in the popular media lately has been telling us that multi-tasking is not really possible; you are in fact splitting your attention and not doing either task as efficiently and effectively as you could by concentrating on a single effort.  Thus, one might infer that comprehending the meaning of the words and experiencing completely the music at the same time is not possible.  However, the science of the brain seems to me to suggest that it is.  Let me offer a quote from "Musicophilia" by Oliver Sachs, p. 226, “A piece of music is not a mere sequence of notes, but a tightly organized organic whole.  Every bar, every phrase arises organically from what preceded it and points to what will follow.  Dynamism is built into the nature of melody.  And over and above this, there is the intentionality of the composer, the style, the order, and the logic which he has created to express his musical ideas and feelings.  These too, are present in every bar and phrase.” This would seem to require attention away from the words.  Yet, he also states, p. 235, that “…there are major differences (and some overlaps) in representation of speech and song in the brain.”  He points to patients with aphasia, the loss of expressive language, who can sing songs including the words that they cannot speak.  It appears that perhaps the two systems, one handling music and one handling speech, normally operate at the same time, and perhaps are capable of reinforcing each other.

In conclusion, I rest my case that music in opera is more important, but will yield to the assertion that without the words, it is not opera.  One might argue that shapes in a painting are more important than the color of the shapes, but one would readily concede that shape and color together create a transcendent experience that either one alone cannot achieve.  So, it is with music and words in opera.  We can debate whether words or music are more important, but thank God, we don’t have to choose.  Spoiler alert - As Countess Madeleine in Capriccio concludes when pressed to choose the ending of the opera her two suitors have produced, and thus choose between them, and words and music, she responds that she cannot choose and asks, “Is there an ending that isn’t trivial?

Classics, a Curveball, and Opera on the Move: Virginia Opera 2016-2017 Season

The Virginia Opera is an opera company that I am just getting to know, and the more I learn, the more impressed I become.  An obvious distinguishing feature for Virginia Opera is that its productions are presented in three different cities in Virginia, always beginning in Norfolk, then moving to Richmond and finishing in Fairfax, or vice versa.  I have attended performances in Fairfax and Richmond and hope to visit the Harrison Opera House in Norfolk in the coming year (seafood and opera sounds good to me).  Another distinguishing feature is its stated goal of having the youngest opera audience in the nation by 2025.  They are backing that commitment with a number of activities, especially involving schools in Virginia.  For example, they offer student nights at performances in Norfolk and Richmond, with modestly priced tickets sold for students and teachers/chaperones in grammar/secondary schools.  One benefit for you of their educational outreach is the online posting of free study guides for 50 commonly performed operas.

Here is the lineup for 2016-2017:

  • Seven Deadly Sins by Kurt Weill/Pagliacci by Ruggero Leoncavallo, Sep 30 – Oct 16
  • The Barber of Seville by Gioachino Rossini, Nov 11 – Dec 4
  • Der Freischutz by Carl Maria von Weber, Jan 27 – Feb 19
  • Turandot by Giacomo Puccini,  March 17 – Apr 2

The curveball:

First up is an unusual pairing (the curveball; baseball season starts Sunday) of a couple of short operas. Pagliacci is a mainstay of opera company repertoires and a beautiful lead role for tenors.  The cast is youngish, but still has experience in many opera houses around the U.S. The usual opera pairing with Pagliacci is Cavalleria Rusticana; it’s sort of expected.  I am not familiar with Seven Deadly Sins, but it sounds almost Hitchcockian.  The main character Anna is played by two performers representing two sides of her personality.   Anna I, the singer, will be played by Austrian soprano Ute Gfrerer, making her debut performance in the U.S.  Anna II, the dancer, will be played by Gabrielle Zucker, a dancer and choreographer who has not only danced, but has created roles for a number U.S. opera companies.  Modern composer Kurt Weill is credited with being one of the most important composers for the theater, though it is not clear that “opera” composer really fits him. Actually, reading about this production made me think it is not to be missed.  Virginia Opera seems to be making a statement with this pairing of intent to update and surprise.

The classics:

On the other hand, I would not be surprised if at any given moment somewhere on earth, or somewhere in distant solar systems, The Barber of Seville is playing.  And the high comedy and spirited music of Rossini justifies them all.  If you are a newbie or just want a delightful evening, this is a good place to start.  I am not familiar with Weber operas in general, or Der Freischutz (The Magic Marksman) in particular, though I have heard passages of his excellent symphonies.  He was influential in the development of early German Opera; Der Freischutz was immediately successful and the only opera in that category to become a standard offering today.  The story involves supernatural and sinister elements, making me think it should have been offered around Halloween.  The lead tenor in the opera is described in the Virginia Opera brochure as a “heldentenor”.  This sounded much to close to some of the supernatural characters on the television show, Grimm; so, I looked it up and it is a tenor with a powerful voice who plays heroes – whew!  I have several fond memories of Turandot.  My family gave me a birthday present of seeing it at the Metropolitan Opera back in October, a stunning opera with gorgeous Puccini music.  The Met had the resources to do a spectacular Franco Zeffirelli staging.  I will be very interested to see how Virginia Opera carries off their production.

A personal wish:  I’d like to see more coverage of the Virginia Opera productions in the Washington Post.

Tickets:

Right now, you can buy season subscriptions at a 10% discount over the price of buying tickets individually for Norfolk and Richmond venues.  I was told by the box office at the GMU Center for the Arts that the Center’s 2016-2017 Season will be announced on April 6, and you then can buy Virginia Opera subscriptions at the discounted price.  A major advantage of the subscription packages is that they offer ticket exchange if you cannot attend a performance for which you hold a ticket.  As mentioned above, check out student night tickets for Norfolk and Richmond; the Center for the Arts in Fairfax offers free tickets to George Mason University students.  While the opera productions are the same at the three venues, the ticket policies of the venues are not necessarily the same; always check policies for the venue you are interested in.  Prices for the subscription packages which include a ticket to all four operas vary by seat and date, ranging from a little under $100 to a little over $500.  I have sat in the mid-level seats and these are quite good in these venues. All tickets include attendance at 45 min pre-performance discussions prior to each opera.

Reminder:

I have already discussed the upcoming performance of The Flying Dutchman in April (The Big Bad Wolf for the Opera Newbie) and dates are listed in the sidebar. 

The Young, the Old, and Dynamic Pricing: Washington National Opera’s 2016-2017 Season

The Washington National Opera which performs at the Kennedy Center has announced its 2016-2017 opera season and it has been reviewed by Washington Post music critic, Anne Midgette; she found the program “deliberately cautious,” offering too much that is familiar, unclear in its goals.  Here are the main attractions; judge for yourself:

  • The Marriage of Figaro by Amadeus Mozart, Sep 22 – Oct 2
  • The Daughter of the Regiment by Gaetano Donizetti, Nov 12 – 20
  • Dead Man Walking by Jake Heggie, Feb 25 – Mar 11
  • Champion by Terrence Blanchard, Mar 4 - 18
  • Madame Butterfly by Giacomo Puccini, May 6 – 21

Even if you are relatively new to opera, you probably have heard of Figaro and Butterfly. With a little more familiarity you likely know of Daughter.  These three are the classic, crowd pleasing selections, hopefully keeping WNO’s budget in the black selections.  You have to have more opera experience than I to know about Dead Man Walking or Champion.  These offerings are presumably born of a desire to offer newer and more Innovative opera.  Well done, that.  I still like Top Forty Opera (my term for the operas you hear over and over again on Met Opera radio), and admittedly with each production, each group of singers and crew adds their own stamp to make it interesting again, sort of like seeing another performance of Hamlet because Meryl Streep is playing Hamlet (I couldn’t think off hand of a male actor of equal stature, and who wouldn’t go see Streep play Hamlet?).  However, I admit my personal trend now is to get more excited about the newer stuff. 

So let's start with the newer stuff:

The story line of Dead Man Walking is taken from the book and movie of the same name.  A death row inmate is listened to and then befriended by nun Sister Helen who attempts to lead him to spiritual salvation before his execution, by all accounts a powerful and moving story.  The opera premiered in 2000 to acclaim.  Sister Helen will be played by Kate Lindsay, a young performer who has drawn much praise of late.  Susan Graham who starred in the premiere of this opera at the Met will also be a featured performer in the WNO production.  I am not familiar with the works of Jake Heggie.  This is the first of several operas and stage works he has composed; he is also known for his songs, choral works, and orchestral music.  The story seems to me to be an ideal one for opera and I look forward to seeing it. 

Different operas affect us each differently because each of us are different.  Champion is based on a real life event that affected me personally.  In 1962, as a teenage fan of boxing I watched on television the welterweight championship fight between Emile Griffith and Benny “Kid” Paret.  I was aware that there was enmity between the two, though I did not know the back story of Paret outing Griffith for being a homosexual.  In the 12th round of the fight, Paret was hit hard and stunned by Griffith. Unfortunately, when he fell back, the ropes caught him and held him up, defenseless.  Griffith continued to pound fierce punches to his head.  The referee did not intercede quickly enough.  Ten days later Paret died of brain injuries.  My interest in boxing died with him.  The focus of the opera is how this event affected Griffith in later years.  He is quoted as saying, "I kill a man and the world forgives me. I love a man and the world wants to kill me." The music for this production is described as a fusion of jazz and opera and I look forward to the new music, though watching it will be painful.

Just a few words about the classic operas:

I saw a fine Virginia Opera performance of The Marriage of Figaro a couple of years ago at George Mason University’s Center for the Arts.  The opera is a delightful comedy that is often recommended for opera newbies.  And you get the great Mozart music.  Much has been said about the role of Susanna in this opera; it will be interesting to see how the popular Lisette Oropesa plays her.  Amanda Majeski plays the Countess which she also played recently at the Met.  I have not seen a performance of Daughter, but I have listened to some of the opera on recordings and like the music; Oropesa stars here again.  I usually like Donizetti’s music with its bel canto style singing.  Rising star tenor Lawrence Brownlee performs lead tenor in this one; in one aria he will be required to hit nine high Cs, which I gather for tenors is like climbing Mt. Everest.  Madame Butterfly is one of my very favorite operas.  Wolf Trap Opera put on a fine performance at the Filene Center last summer.  The key to this opera for me is who plays Cio-Cio San.  My all-time favorite performer for this role is the super fabulous Renata Scotto (I am bowing and repeating I am not worthy) who no longer performs, but the recordings are a must listen.  Ermonela Jaho and Hei-Kyung Hong will alternate in this role for WNO.  I am not familiar with either, but both are established, highly-acclaimed performers.  The difficulty will be in choosing which one you go see (or you could do both).  And you get the gorgeous Puccini music.

Now to ticket information and dynamic pricing: 

Currently you can purchase subscriptions for these five operas at a 10% discount over single ticket prices; individual tickets are not on sale as yet.  Actually, it could prove to be more than a 10% discount.  The Kennedy Center uses dynamic pricing for its performances; that is, if demand is great, the seat you want could cost more, closer to the time of the performance.  I found this out the hard way in buying my tickets recently for the Ring Cycle.  The subscription prices for seats to the main operas vary depending on their seating location, ranging from around $1100 to $240; this covers a ticket for all five operas.  A big advantage of the subscription packages is the added feature of ticket exchange.  If later, you cannot make the performance that you have a ticket for, Kennedy Center will allow you to exchange your ticket for a different date of the same opera.  I bought one subscription package for 2016-2017 for myself.  My wife and son were not ready to commit to all the operas, but if we get tickets for them later, I can trade mine in for a seat next to them. 

WNO/Kennedy Center offers several other worthwhile related short operas/concerts/events for the 2016-2017 season.  One I will mention is "Justice at the Opera" with Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, which will deal with themes raised in Walking and Champion.  Purchasers of subscription packages have the option to also purchase now individual tickets to these events.  Be sure to check the schedule.

The Big Bad Wolf for the Opera Newbie

BILO, before I liked opera, I had the impression that operas by Richard Wagner were everything that turned me off to opera, but admittedly, based on very little music listening.  I found Mark Twain’s famous quip, “Wagner’s music is better than it sounds,” not only to be amusing, but pretty much on target.  So, AILO, after I liked opera, I was still intimidated by Wagner.  Whenever it came on when I was listening to radio, I thought it was too intense to listen to.  Even now I sometimes find it a bit much before noon.  What to do?  I decided that I would not listen to Wagnerian operas for a year or two, and then take the leap with the Ring.  Sort of soften up my opera resistance before getting into the ring with such a heavyweight.       

I’m not sure how long I waited, but somewhere further down the road, I ran across a recording called, “An Introduction to Wagner – The Flying Dutchman (David Timson, 2002),” one of the recordings in the “Opera Explained” series.  This opera was considered by Wagner to be the beginning of his opera career, even though it was not his first opera.  It features myth and romantic themes that would characterize his later operas.  I think it might be Wagner’s most accessible opera.  This recording broke the opera down into its elements and provided commentary with musical selections.  Ah, I thought, Wagner’s music is better than it sounds. Just joking, but by placing focus on the music itself and what Wagner was trying to achieve, my apprehension faded and I could enjoy the opera more.  I learned about Wagner’s motifs, musical themes he used to represent characters or ideas in the opera.  I began to appreciate Wagner’s ability to create music that supported and helped tell the story.  My strongest impressions of Wagner’s music in this introduction were his incredible use of the brass section of the orchestra and his ability to sustain moods by painting them with music that didn’t seem to progress with typical melodies, but just hang there as a backdrop, sustaining the mood almost endlessly.  Listening to this recording (more that once) proved to be an effective method to get to know Wagner.  So, I recommend the Dutchman to you, and now I am a big Wagner fan and really love his music/operas.    

And, it is about to be Wagner season in the Washington area.  First up in April, Virginia Opera is presenting The Flying Dutchman (you may also see the opera titled in German as Der Fliegende Hollander).  As usual performances will be presented in Norfolk, Fairfax, and Richmond; dates are listed in the blog sidebar.  Later that month, Washington National Opera will begin presenting the Ring Cycle at the Kennedy Center.  The dates for the performances of the four operas of the Ring, that includes The Rhinegold, The ValkyrieSiegfried, and Twilight of the Gods, are also listed in the sidebar.  I will have more to say about the Ring later, which is a really big deal for opera fans.  If you have any interest, buy your tickets now.  These operas are already mostly sold out, and I must warn you, these tickets are not cheap!

Wolf Trap Opera: The Lucretia Project, and Streaming Ghosts for Free

Wolf Trap Opera continues to impress.  WTO’s first opera of the summer season is The Rape of Lucretia, which of course deals with a very sensitive subject.  This might raise some concern among potential attendees.  Some opera companies of late have created controversies by enhancing the sexual/violent aspects of their productions beyond the traditional, presumably to increase attendance.  Kim Pensinger Witman, Director of WTO, noted in her blog post on the summer season that this opera is presented “within an extremely thoughtful and delicate framework.”  However, she and WTO go even further to address the issues forthrightly by planning a “Lucretia Project” consisting of four events to precede the opera:  the “Lucretia Symposium” will discuss issues around artistic presentation of sensitive subjects; the “Read Lucretia” forum will explore narrative treatments of the story; “Hear Lucretia” will offer music and poetry around the Lucretia story; and, “See Lucretia” will examine the treatment of the legend by visual artists.  What a wonderful way to immerse oneself in this cultural experience!    

Never seeming to rest, WTO has just announced that last year’s performance of The Ghosts of Versailles is now available for streaming on your electronic devices for a limited time period, the first WTO performance to be made available by streaming.  My son and I attended the performance live last year and thought it was one of the most enjoyable performances we have seen.  I do recommend reading a synopsis of the opera prior to viewing it; the story is rather involved and complex.  It is linked to Beaumarchais’ Figaro trilology; the first two plays were used as the storylines for The Barber of Seville and The Marriage of Figaro and Ghosts incorporates elements of the third play, The Guilty Mother. In the opera, the ghost of Beaumarchais seeks to help the ghost of Marie Antoinette come to terms with her execution.  Composer John Corigliano and librettist William M. Hoffman were commissioned by Met Opera to produce this new opera with a premier at the Met in 1991.  The music is at times beautiful and at times eerie, befitting of ghosts; in 2000, Corigliano turned the music into an orchestral suite titled Phantasmagoria.  I suspect that we might see more streaming from WTO, but not likely to remain free.  So, take advantage while you can – click here.

Thing Two: "For Parents"

Following up my Thing One post on May 19 about Opera Ed To Go, one of two long-term projects on OperaGene that seek reader contributions, I now present Thing Two, a project aimed at helping parents who want to introduce their kids to opera.  A colleague at work told me her young daughter had enjoyed watching an DVD recording of The Magic Flute that I had loaned to her.  Yes, not only do adults sometimes like this stuff, but occasionally a kid will too.  But, it made me think.  What are some other operas I could recommend that would be good for kids?  Operas tend to portray grand passions and may not be age appropriate.  That raises other questions as well: at what age should kids be introduced to opera?  How best to introduce opera to them?  I am definitely not able to answer those questions.  Anne Midgette, classical music critic, for the Washington Post wrote an article published on January 9 for this topic titled, “How a classical critic introduced her child to music (not very well),”in which she had to conclude that she had thoughts and experiences, but not answers; she did recommend a classic music CD for kids titled, “A House Filled with Music,” by Margret and Rolf Rettich and a book called, “Welcome to the Symphony.”  CD music and book sellers tend to carry a few items directed to kids, but it is helpful to get an expert recommendation.  She expects her article to be the first in a series on the topic over time; keep an eye out for others.       

I found a few other sources that offer advice.  One I found with reasonable suggestions you can implement was a piece on the Opera Teen blog, called, “Ten Easy Ways to Get Kids Into Opera.” Sadly, the author rightly points out that with what kids are watching on television these days, age appropriate is not the concern it used to be.  The Guardian published an article titled, “The 10 Best: Operas for Children,” which lists mainly operas specifically written for children; I have to admit that I am not familiar with many of these.  I would like to make a modest proposal of mine: Tell your kids that opera and classical music are absolutely not to be listened to until they are grown up.  I predict you will find them taking headphones to the bathroom and locking the door; older kids will head out with claims they are going to a rock concert, but in fact head down to the Kennedy Center.  I am joking, but introducing things to kids is good, trying to force it not so much.  People like what they like even as kids, but have hope, that may very well change over time.  My daughters rarely listen to classical music, but my son rarely listens to anything else.  My interest in opera started only about five years ago.  Genetics plays a role as well as parental influence, and gene expression patterns can change over time.       

I suspect that for musical families this is not really an issue, with music being a part of their kids lives early on.  However, I wonder what the experience of musical families is with kids and opera specifically.  My sister asked someone who played music for her church and was a fine musician if she liked opera, and her response was an emphatic no way.  Not even all musicians like opera.     

Now to get back to the “For Parents” section of the website:  the goal for this section is simply to offer parents links to useful materials and advice when they want to introduce their kids to opera.  I will definitely leave the parenting up to the parents! I do, however, seek reader input and contributions for the page, especially things that have worked for them.  All suggestions of good operas for kids and/or introductory materials will be much appreciated.

Plotkin’s 40 Great Next Gen Opera Singers

If you are like me you love articles with lists, i.e., top ten lists, 5 things you should know about X lists, the 7 best foods for you lists, etc.  It is also fun to see lists of up and coming young talent.  Well, here are two lists from opera authority, Fred Plotkin, that are of that type, his list of 15 great male opera singers under 40 and his list of 25 great female opera singers under 40.  I am just getting to know Mr. Plotkin’s background, but he is a writer/blogger for Operavore, the author of Opera 101: A Complete Guide to Learning and Loving Opera, and has served as a performance manager for Met Opera.  So, he has reasonable credentials to publish lists, at least for the fun of checking them out.  Note that these are "great lists", not “best lists,” and indeed one of his criteria is that he has personally heard them sing.  I present them here for your enjoyment and a chance to get to know some of the fine, young performers you might be seeing and hearing in the future.  A helpful feature of his lists is that clips of the selectees singing are included for many of the young performers.  His lists also make clear the international scope of opera. 

His list of great male singers under 40 includes several who have performed in the mid-Atlantic; notably, Steven LaBrie just performed at the Lyric Opera Baltimore and Daniel Brenna will play Siegfried in May in Washington National Opera’s Ring Cyclehttp://www.wqxr.org/?utm_source=sharedUrl&utm_medium=metatag&utm_campaign=sharedUrl#!/story/forty-more-under-forty-next-generation-great-opera-singers-part-one/?utm_source=local&utm_medium=treatment&utm_campaign=carousel&utm_content=item2.   

His list of female greats under 40 includes Isabelle Leonard whom I heard in Cold Mountain in Philadelphia this year; I especially recommend listening to the clip of Nadine Sierra singing Caro Nome from Rigoletto, one of my favorite operas:  http://www.wqxr.org/?utm_source=sharedUrl&utm_medium=metatag&utm_campaign=sharedUrl#!/story/forty-more-under-forty-next-generation-great-opera-singers-part-2/.  

Mr. Plotkin makes clear that he produced these lists to make these singers’ names familiar to opera fans, and I commend him for this.

Thing One: "Opera Ed" Now "Opera Ed To Go"

There are a couple of things on OperaGene that are long term projects and frankly I could use help finding examples.  I have devoted sections on the website to both thing one and thing two.  The first thing is opera education or Opera Ed for short.  Now, there is a tremendous, let me repeat, tremendous, amount of information available about opera.  These days there is an overwhelming amount of information easily accessible about everything just by computers/mobile devices alone.  But saying this is a little like saying, “You want to make friends?  Here is the world.  There are 7 billion people in here.  Make friends.”  It is true and relevant, but not all that helpful.  Plus, who these days has time for friends.  I hope I am joking, though I recall the MIT mantra: sleep, good grades, social life; pick any two.  Time pressure rules most of us these days and the first things to be sacrificed tend to be the soft subjects, the things we need, but that don’t seem urgent.  Like music. 

Ok, I’m getting a little off track here.  I am going to assume we agree that learning more about a topic, like learning more about a friend, enhances our appreciation of the subject of our attention and allows us to derive the most pleasure from the relationship.  So, it is with opera.  The question is how can we identify the most useful information, organize the information available so that it is subservient to us, and make it work for our schedule.  Here the analogy to friends breaks down, at least the subservient part.  The internet is a great source for information, but I think we are less likely to read things or watch things on the internet the longer the length.  So, for Opera Ed, I will try to post the most interesting and relevant information I can find and organize the information to make clear what it offers you, but always with an eye to the time required.  For these reasons I have renamed this section as Opera Ed To Go. 

I will list some opportunities for opera education on the page that are more time-consuming and offer a bigger payoff, (I am a fan of and truly value in depth learning) but the main focus of the Opera Ed To Go page, and what I hope to grow over time, will be teaching moments, online content that lasts about one to five minutes that is also entertaining.  I am looking for moments that teach us something about a specific opera, or opera in general, or music in general that educates us painlessly and increases the non-expert’s awareness of music and opera, creates an Ahhh moment, where the opera fan says internally, “Oh, I get it.”  Short time commitment, entertaining – people might try it.  One I have listed so far that best represents what I am going for is rather clunky in its navigation, sorry; you have to sweep through a longer web post to pick out the moments, but it provides insight into how Verdi used music to create tension.  Check it out on the Opera To Go page

If you are trained in music and opera, Opera Ed To Go will not be your page to peruse, but it could be your page to contribute to.  In fact, I especially appeal to folks trained in opera and music.  If you are not trained in these areas, it can be your page to contribute to as well if you run across Opera Ed To Go moments that strike you as helpful, and you want to share.  Point these out to me, please.  I will keep plugging away, but all contributions will be gratefully received.  

Thing two, the “For Parents” section, will be covered in a follow up posting.

Heads Up Opera Fans! This Saturday, March 19

Wolf Trap summer tickets, including opera tickets, go on sale to the general public at 10 am, Saturday, March 19 at several price levels!  Check your schedules for the periods June 10-18, Jul 15-23, and Friday, Aug 5 and go online to http://www.wolftrap.org/opera.aspx to pick your seats.

I feel very comfortable enthusiastically recommending Wolftrap Opera to you.  WTO Director Kim Pensinger Witman and her colleagues spend much of each Fall staging auditions around the country in order to select young performers for the much vied-for Filene Young Artists program.  The operas to be performed are not decided until the young artists are selected to make the best fit.  The talent level performing at these operas is thus very high.  Many of these singers will go on to careers in the top opera houses across the U.S.  Wolf Trap Opera can point to a legion of young singers who honed their craft there and moved on to successful singing careers.  The staging for these operas, though not as elaborate as you will see at the major opera venues, surprises and delights with creativity, enhancing the telling of the story.  There are many exceptional individuals involved in these productions.  The WTO website is chock full of information and details on their programs and artists.  I only really became aware of WTO in the last couple of years.  I attended Don Giovanni two years ago and The Ghosts of Versaille last year, both in the Barns location, a small indoor, rustic theater, and Madama Butterfly last year in the outdoor, but covered Filene Center (many families have picnics there prior to the performance).  All were excellent, but my son and I thought Ghosts was about as good theater as we have seen anywhere.  Supertitles providing English translations are available at both locations.

I am actually kind of excited about the two being staged at the Barns.  Benjamin Britten (b.1913-d.1976) is a composer from the modern era and I am looking forward to sampling his music firsthand.  The Rape of Lucretia is based on a historical legend from Roman history.  Britten and colleagues were trying to produce works at the least possible expense, presumably to increase their accessibility, and Britten referred to Lucretia as a chamber opera.  An interesting feature of the opera is two two-person choruses with a two-male chorus covering thoughts of the male lead and a two-female chorus explaining the thoughts of the female lead.  It all sounds very interesting. 

L’Opera Seria (1769) by Bohemian composer Florian Gassmann (b.1729-d.1774) has played to recent acclaim in Europe according to Ms. Witman, though he is apparently better known for well regarded symphonies and chamber music.  A fall from a carriage led to his untimely death.  I read that the opera is a satire on the state of opera seria in his day (opera seria is defined in Wikipedia as an Italian musical term which refers to the noble and “serious” style of Italian opera that predominated in Europe from 1710 to 1770).  I am not familiar with this opera or the composer’s work, but given that the lead sopranos are named Smirky, Out-of-Tune, and Purple-Face, I am willing to venture that it is a comedy.  And I am willing to bet that the young performers will extract every ounce of enjoyment from it for your evening’s pleasure. 

The selection for the Filene Center is La Boheme on August 5.  The performances in the Filene Center also include the National Symphony Orchesta; no small benefit that.  Operas selected for the Filene Center are intended to appeal to a wider audience by staging them in a fun and popular location, and in particular, to appeal to people who might want to try out opera to see if they like it.  At last year’s Butterfly, I was amazed and pleased by the number of young people in the audience.  Our genes, including the opera gene are often repressed until some event releases them.  You will see most experts recommending La Boheme as an opera for newbies because it is so accessible, a drama that will touch your heart and which offers simply gorgeous music by Puccini (remember the NSO will be playing it). 

One final suggestion is to get there early enough to hear the pre-opera talk.  I think my son and I would have been a little lost had we not heard Ms. Witman’s explanation of Ghosts and its background.  These talks are definitely recommended.   

Sometimes It Happens Like That

Yesterday, I headed for home after dropping my son off at college and turned on Met Opera Radio as I pulled out, a little after three.  Three o’clock in the afternoon is one of the times during the day that is a start time for the next complete opera to be played.  The host said that the station was featuring soprano Renee Fleming this week in celebration of her 25th year of performing at the Met, having made her debut in 1991.  The host stated that Ms. Fleming had selected three performances to be featured and that one of those was next to be played, Charles Gounod’s Faust.  I have heard parts of Faust many times and watched a performance on DVD.  For me, Gounod’s music is among the prettiest in opera, second maybe only to Puccini.  So, I was looking forward to a pleasant ride home.  What I got was nothing short of thrilling.  Renee Fleming’s singing was at a level I had not experienced listening to her before and I am a fan; I love her voice and have listened to several of her recordings and opera recordings featuring her.  At times in this version of Faust she soared like an angel swooping about in the heavens.  Her flourishes and ability to extend and hold notes almost lifted me out of my seat, not a good position for the driver.  The opera also featured an overall impressive cast, including Richard Leech, a tenor, and Sam Ramey, a bass-baritone, and conductor Julius Rudel, in a 1997 appearance at the Met; the performers seemed to take inspiration from each other and gave an inspired, cohesive presentation.  For me, this was opera at the Mt. Olympus level.

I was only able to listen to Act l and part of Act ll before reaching home.  When I got home, I searched for a recording of this performance.  Unfortunately, there does not appear to be a CD recording available, at least that I could find.  There is a DVD version available in Met Opera on Demand.  This service costs $150 per year or $15 per month on a monthly basis.  However, it looked like I can rent it for $3.99, and a free seven day trial is offered.  Could be in my future. 

Normally I prefer to pick and schedule what I watch or listen to.  However, going with the flow and just listening to whatever the radio sends your way can provide unexpected delights.  Sometimes it happens like that.

Affordable Opera, part 2

Think about what music you especially like and then think about how many live performances you have seen in the last two years.  If you are like most people, not many.  I think for most of us we have pursued our interest in music mainly by buying albums and listening on the radio, though streaming services, below, are changing that.  It is easy, convenient and quite enjoyable.  I will tell a story that is a little off the track before returning to the question at hand, namely how to enjoy opera more affordably.  I claim the best audio equipment I ever owned was a small table radio with a single four-inch speaker.  I think it was the Admiral brand, and I inherited it from an aunt and uncle because it had been dropped and the plastic cover was partly torn off.  I was a young teen, growing up in Columbus, GA, and at night in the late fifties I lay awake and listened on local radio stations to the birth of rock and roll.  I can’t claim that anything since has sounded quite that good.  If the music touches you, it is good no matter how you listen.

Ok, first let’s talk about radio and streaming, both separately and together.  I have subscribed to XM/SIRIUS radio, a for pay satellite radio service, for about ten years.  When I first developed an interest in opera, my go to channel was Met Opera Radio on XM radio, which broadcasts opera 24/7, a mix of complete operas and single arias.  For the last five years when I am in the car, Met Opera Radio is playing; this has been a big part of my listening to opera.  Opera-focused stand-alone radio stations that are free are not available in most areas, but if you are in range of a PBS station you can hear the live Saturday afternoon Met Opera radio broadcasts; check here to find the station closest to you.  WETA-FM in Washington DC area is a PBS station that also offers an opera at 8 pm feature.  Some large cities offer opera stations, like Operavore in New York City.

Computers and mobile electronic devices, smart phones, portable players, and tablets are changing how many, maybe most, of us access music. Couple that with internet streaming services like Pandora, Spotify, Apple Music, and others, and we have almost unlimited access to the music of our choosing.  Pandora and Spotify offer free versions in addition to commercial-free pay plans.  For about $12 a month you can sign up for a streaming service that gives you uninterrupted access to a large share of recorded music.  If you buy on the average one album per month, the streaming services are a good value.  You can also access opera on radio stations available online from across the U.S. and the world.  Even the stand alone radio stations mentioned above are available for listening online.  And there are apps to help you.  I purchased the TuneIn app and listen to opera radio stations using that app.  I remember when I was a teenager I signed up for the Columbia Record Club.  I was sent four LP albums for classical music for the promise that I would buy four more albums in the next two years.  It was a big step forward, but I was limited in music and rich in time to listen to the albums.  Now, the situation has reversed; I am rich in music and limited in time.

I will mention two more ways to access opera affordably.  One is YouTube.  Sometimes I think you can find almost anything on youtube.com.  The sound quality is not always great, but what you can find by searching for your favorite aria, opera, or opera singer can be fun.  I use it as an audio encyclopedia.  I sometimes like to conduct my own version of The Voice using YouTube.  I search on a favorite aria or singer, and see how many notable singers, both current and past, pop up.  I can compare the great ones singing the same aria for me.  The final method I will list is the good old pubic library.  My son is in college now, but just a couple of years ago we were frequent visitors to the public library for his school research and book borrowing.  Most libraries now have CD and DVD collections of movies, plays, and music that you can check out.  Public libraries are fun to visit and explore at no cost, unless of course you incur late fees for not getting things back on time. 

In conclusion, I didn’t actually count the ways, but If you have the opera gene, I hope you will concede that there are many ways to enjoy opera affordably.

Affordable Opera, part 1

A visitor to OperaGene told me that she could not afford attending operas now and suggested adding an Affordable Opera section to the website; I am considering it.  In my blog post on February 29 titled “First, a Positive Message:  No, No, and No,” I made the assertion that you do not have to be rich to enjoy opera, but admitted attending opera is not a cheap proposition.  It is probably not more or much more expensive than attending pop music concerts, plays, or sporting events, but top-rate, live entertainment these days is expensive across the board.  Not every opera fan has the wherewithal to attend these events; I can’t attend them as often as I would like. 

So, how can you enjoy opera more affordably?  Let me count the ways.  First, check out offerings at some of the smaller venues offering live opera.  For example, in my area Wolf Trap Opera offers excellent productions in the summer using up and coming young performers; tickets go on sale on March 19.  Not too expensive tickets can be had; La Boheme can be seen for $25-75 in the outdoor Filene Center this summer.  Next down come the cinema showings of live and recorded operas for about $25 per ticket; these include air conditioning and more comfortable seats.  My blog post of March 2 titled “Pretty Good Value: the Met Opera Live-in-HD Cinema” discussed one series.  The reader who suggested the Affordable Opera page brought another cinema series to my attention.  The Royal Opera House of London also broadcasts a live-in-cinemas series, though to only a very limited number of theaters in the mid-Atlantic region if I am reading the map correctly; click here to see a performance list and enter your address into the box to find theaters that carry these in your area. I have added these performances to this blog’s side bar listing of performances (the side bar may appear on the bottom of the screen on some mobile devices).  The next scheduled live performance is Boris Godunov on March 21.

There are three other ways to view Met Opera Live-in-HD Cinema videos, two expensive and sure; the other free, but requires some searching.  Met Opera offers the videos for sale through the usual sources and places (Amazon; iTunes; their own shop; etc.), typically in the $25-30 range for most operas on DVD.  Met Opera also places these recordings into it own program of Opera on Demand.  For about $150 per year or $15 per month, you can have 24/7 access to their opera video library on your computers and most mobile devices.  Their library also includes television performances and audio-only performances.  There are 550 broadcasts available, and considering they are adding new ones on at least a monthly basis, you will probably never watch/listen to them all.  Of course, the more operas you watch, the better value this method becomes.  A great way to view many of these videos for free is to tune into the Great Performances at the Met broadcasts on PBS television.  Check here to track these down in your area.  I simply have my DVR set to record Great Performances at the Met.  Over the last two years I have recorded about 25 opera performances this way.  I find viewing these on my own devices has a few advantages:  I can pause the videos when I leave the room, or I can watch them in portions and even watch them multiple times; also, when I miss something, I can use my remote control to go back a few seconds to see it again.  Of course, the selection on PBS is limited and the availability is episodic. 

I have focused mainly on the Met Opera videos because the quality I have seen is typically good and their catalog is extensive.  If you wish to purchase opera videos from vendors such as Amazon or iTunes, your will have a wide selection of performances by other opera companies as well.  I recommend reading online reviews of any opera performance before making the purchase.

In the forthcoming part II, we will explore radio, streaming services, online sources, and the public library.